Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Ribeye Steak Sandwich
Italian Chicken Sandwich
Full Rack 1/2 Rack
2 piece / 4 piece
About
The Broken Spur Steak and Seafood
Welcome to The Broken Spur Steak and Seafood, where the art of grilling meets the elegance of seafood in a delightful dining setting. Nestled in the picturesque town of Mauston, Wisconsin, this gem at 102 Lodge Ln serves up a culinary experience that's hard to forget.
The Broken Spur’s menu is a lover’s stroll through a landscape of mouthwatering dishes. Their steaks are the undisputed stars, with options like the 14oz Ribeye Steak Sandwich, perfectly grilled and crowned with roasted garlic butter, and the 22oz Bone-In Ribeye, which promises a satisfying robust flavor with every bite. Seafood enthusiasts can also indulge in the freshness of Atlantic scallops, seared and elegantly presented atop crispy pork belly.
- Appetizers: Start your meal the right way with their Traditional Bruschetta topped with fresh ingredients, or dive into the crispy goodness of their Fried Cheese Curds, a true Wisconsin delight.
- Broasted Chicken & Ribs: Indulge in the juicy, flavorful broasted chicken paired with fall-off-the-bone ribs—perfect for a hearty appetite.
The atmosphere at The Broken Spur enhances the dining experience. Customers rave about the vibrant ambiance and the care taken to create a welcoming space. The reviews shine a light on the fantastic teamwork among the staff, making for a pleasant evening.
However, as with any establishment, experiences may vary. While guests like Jimmy Lawrence have praised the food and ambiance, service consistency appears to be an area for improvement. Despite that, many diners, including Alison Brown and Jennifer Thatcher, have found solace in the extraordinary dishes and welcoming environment.
Whether you’re an avid steak lover, a seafood aficionado, or simply someone searching for a special night out, The Broken Spur Steak and Seafood is sure to not just meet but exceed your culinary expectations. Don’t hesitate to join the ranks of satisfied patrons discovering one of Mauston’s finest dining establishments!
For reservations or inquiries, you can reach them at +1 608-747-2200. Experience the best of steak and seafood dining at The Broken Spur, where every meal is a celebration of flavor.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Food in this restaurant is fabulous. Cooked and seasoned to perfection. The hostess made a great effort to get us a table as we didn't have a reservation. The bartender was excellent as we enjoyed a cocktail while we waited. Our server on the other hand not so good. She must have wanted to be somewhere else because she didn't seem care about our table. After delivering our meals never returned to check on anything. Had go to bar area and as bartender for 2 cocktails which she made and delivered to our table. When she did return with the check I asked what happened to shrimp cocktail I ordered she said she must have forgotten about it but would go get it. Hopefully if you go to dine there you get a different server because the food and atmosphere is fabulous. ”
“ The food was delicious! Pleasantly surprised and we will come back again for the Prime Rib French dip. Yummy! ”
“ Awesome place. Great food and staff. On the pricey side but you get what you pay for. Make sure to try the cowgirl martini ”
“ Drinks are cheaper than most in the area. Before the meal they brought out crackers, pickled herring, dip and cheese curds. I love all their included appetizers. We got bruschetta, which was about 6 small pieces of bread but was good for 10. I ordered walleye and it was wonderful with crispy breading and it barely even fit on my plate. Asparagus was well cooked. I’ve come here a few times and I’ve never had anything bad to say about it. Will be coming back again. ”
“ Absolutely amazing steaks and lobster. Drinks were well poured. Fast and friendly service with a smile. Great teamwork amongst the staff. Tony even came to the table and spoke with my husband. We've now found our special date night place. We've been searching for one since moved here in late September of 21. Will definitely return. ”
“ The food was amazing. I had the baked french onion soup and the smoked ribs and my husband had the salad and the 14oz. ribeye steak. The soup on it's own is a meal and I would drive the 2.5 hour trip again just to eat that soup. The death by chocolate cake dessert is delicious. Our server, Kari, was friendly, had a good sense of humor, and made the meal worth every penny. ”
“ Incredible experience and food. Table starters were garlic herb cheese, cheese curds, crackers and sardines. Also had pumpernickel bread. I got the burger which felt like half pound, the fries were excellent. Might have been the best French onion soup I've ever had, flavorful. The steaks aren't necessarily cheap but it was the best 14 burger I've ever had, and would have been happy paying 20. The gentleman serving us had a great mood and was very friendly. ”
“ Had an amazing time and pretty good dinner last night. This is definitely a place to go for location rather than actual food quality. The staff was AMAZING! Jill, Alexis and Carry (sorry if I misspelled any names) were all made sure we had the greatest time. The onion soup was my absolute favorite part of the meal. ”